Ryan Howard stared back at the umpire wondering how he could call a 3-2 pitch right down the middle of the plate with 2-out in the bottom of the 9th could be called a strike. Howard looked like Mickey Rivers trying to work a walk in 1978 rather than one of the most feared power hitters in the game; it was as though Howard was wishing he could walk so he didn’t have to be “the man”. Matter of fact, many of the Phillies looked befuddled and bewildered against the Giants pitching as San Francisco eliminated the 2-time defending NL Champions in 6 games sending the Phillies into a winter of questions.
The Phillies prided themselves on developing their own players while winning the 2008 World Series largely with a group of homegrown talent including Howard, Utley, Rollins and pitching star Cole Hamels. As is the case with winning it can become addictive thus the Phillies spent much of the past two-years gutting their farm system in search of the next World title.
Unfortunately for the Phils, destiny was not on their side and instead of heading into 2011 with a 2nd World Championship in 3-years; they are left with $143mm of committed payroll for next year. Due to their bloated payroll there is a fairly good chance that All-Star RF Jayson Werth will leave via free agency and be replaced by the organization’s best prospect, Dominic Brown. This will leave an already imbalanced left-handed lineup even more imbalanced and susceptible to left-handed pitching. (Bruce Bochey exposed that weakness in the NLCS)
While Cole Hamels hadn’t even approached his pitching prime, the Phils have two star pitchers making more than $32 mm annually combined in Halladay and Oswalt who are approaching their mid-30s. The Phillies also have age in left-field with Raul Ibanez and at 3B with Placido Palanco. In other words, there are needs to be addressed but no immediate help coming from below; why is that?
In the summer of 2009 in their pursuit of Cliff Lee, the Phillies traded a lot of good prospects to Cleveland, this in and of itself was not a bad thing because Lee propelled the Phils to the NL Title. However in their quest for Roy Halladay last off-season, the Phillies traded many of their best prospects to Toronto. Then, rather than holding onto Lee for 2010 and then allowing him to walk after this season thereby getting two sandwich picks between the first and second round of the draft in return; the Phillies traded Lee to Seattle to restock their farm system. The basket of prospects returned from Seattle for Lee was nowhere near the quality that was sent to Toronto for Halladay.
In the summer of 2010, going for the title this year, the Phillies then traded another boatload of picks to Houston for Roy Oswalt and assumed the last two-years of his bloated contract in the process. What does all this mean? Well, what it means to me is that next year the Phillies will contend for the NL East title once again but the organization has a lot of mending to do down on the farm as they have gutted a lot of their system over the past two-years. Couple the preceding, with the $143mm payroll for 2011 already committed to and in place along with the aging cast of core players, and it’s not a stretch to see the Phillies slide back toward mediocrity in 2012 and beyond- a place the organization should be quite comfortable with given their 125 year history.